The Sky is Falling

I read an article in Maclean’s earlier this month and was truly
taken-a-back by the bold call for a housing meltdown. Interestingly, recently
in the Financial Post, columnist Andrew Coyne wrote a great article
encapsulating the sentiment around the media selling fear over facts. I find it
interesting how many articles have the bold “sky is falling” headlines however
if you read through the article, they typically point to a balanced market. I
guess balanced headlines don’t sell papers. Anyhow, take a read when you have a
minute and  as always, feel free to use any of my email materials to forward to your clients, we’re here to help.

Hope you enjoy the rest of your day and week.

Harbingers of doom

Even by Maclean’s standards, the cover was alarming. “You’re
about to get burned,” screamed the headline, over a picture of a house that was
literally on fire. “Canada looks like the US before its devastating housing
crash — maybe even worse.” And the kicker, for those still hesitating: “Why
it’s officially time to panic.”

This last was doubtless something of a little in-joke. For my old colleagues at Canada’s newsweekly, it is always
time to panic, especially about house prices. The magazine’s editors inhabit a
world beset by all manner of hitherto undetected demons, from more expensive
groceries (“sudden shortages, riots over prices, the world food crisis is about
to hit home”) to insomnia (“the truth about a modern epidemic”).

But nothing, nothing frightens the magazine or, it is hoped, its readers, more than real estate. For years
Maclean’s has been shuddering in terror of the imminent collapse of the
Canadian housing market. From the relative calm of its late 2007 cover story
(“Buy? Sell? Panic?”), the magazine soon picked up signals of the coming
apocalypse. “House prices start to fall,” the magazine announced the following
summer. By autumn, with the world financial crisis in full swing, so was
Maclean’s. “Canada’s Looming Real Estate Crisis,” the cover shouted: “Why house
prices may soon fall through the floor.”

As the months wore on, and the cataclysm failed to arrive, Maclean’s remained ever hopeful of a real collapse.
But durned if prices, after a brief dip, resumed rising. By June 2008, a grumpy
Maclean’s was warning readers “Don’t believe the housing hype,” insisting there
are “plenty of signs that the Canadian housing market is still on some very
shaky ground,” even if “average home prices are up more than 16 per cent this year.”

Fast forward through several more stories in the same vein and by this year the magazine and others were in even
less doubt: Canada was in a housing bubble. Why, just look at the numbers. For
starters, there’s the oft-repeated fact that Canadians are carrying debts worth
153% of their annual income. That’s true: but other countries’ citizens manage
much heavier debt loads, from the spendthrift Swiss (200%) to the feckless
Dutch (260%) to the profligate Danes (320%). We may be carrying almost as much
debt as the Americans before the crash, but with nothing like the same risk
factors, from subprime mortgages to small regional banks, that made their
economy such a firetrap. And if we’re mentioning how Canadians’ debts have
grown, we should surely also mention that their assets have as well: still five
times as large as their debts.

Mortgage costs, interests and principal combined, are currently running at about 30% of disposable income
— again, higher than a few years ago, but barely half what they were in the
early 1990s. Yes, house prices were still rising as of year-end, but more
slowly than before, as even the Maclean’s piece acknowledges — though somehow
it cites this as evidence for its doomsday thesis. But then, what doesn’t? If
prices were rising quickly, that would be proof of housing “mania.” If they
fell a little, that would be the bubble starting to burst. And if they fell a
lot? Look out below!

The truth is the real estate market is cooling slightly, helped by a modest
tightening of lending regulations. It’s true that a rise in interest rates from
current, historically low levels would put some homeowners in distress, but
they’d have to spike a long way before the damage grew widespread to full blown
panic. Andrew Coyne Apr10, 2012 –

Beaten Down Prices & Banks Fighting for Mortgage Business open Window of Opportunity for Buyers this Spring…

Why the latest mortgage war was months in the making:

Before it waded back  into the market with deeply discounted mortgage rates last week, Bank of
Montreal sought to give policy makers in Ottawa a heads-up that it was about to shake up the housing market again.

The bank had also spent months amassing a stockpile of cheap funding in the bond market to backstop the discounted mortgages, a strategy
designed to ensure the cut-rate loans would not lose the bank money.

The parallel moves show the strategic manoeuvring that has gone on behind the scenes to set the
stage for Canada’s latest price war on mortgages. Most major lenders are now locked in battle, offering historic low rates.

After reports Ottawa was uncomfortable when the bank began offering record-low mortgage rates in
January, amid ongoing warnings of household debt, BMO signalled another price cut was coming in an effort to explain its rationale, sources said.

That was before BMO’s announcement last week that it would reintroduce five-year fixed rate mortgages at 2.99 per cent, after testing them in January, and 10-year mortgages at 3.99 per cent. The move cascaded through the sector, causing a flurry of price-matching by rival banks.

It has also spawned mudslinging between the country’s biggest lenders. Royal Bank of Canada has taken out ads across the country to combat BMO’s publicity push, pointing out
fine-print restrictions on BMO’s mortgage offers compared to its own. That prompted a flurry of rebuttal ads from BMO.

Meanwhile, CIBC has launched a cash-back campaign hoping to lure customers of other banks to switch lenders.

In an interview, Bank of Montreal chief executive officer Bill Downe said his bank took steps to ready itself for the attack on prices. “We were able to plan for that offer in a way that preserved our margins,” Mr. Downe said.

The bank has been stockpiling cheaper funding in the bond market over months, which it planned to unleash in advance of the spring mortgage season. The move has left rival banks with little choice but to introduce comparable rates on a variety of offerings, even though some are facing unattractive margins.

Royal Bank of Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and a host of others, including credit unions, have put similar mortgage promotions in the market, usually involving 4-year fixed rates and 30-year amortizations, as opposed to BMO’s offer of 25-years and a five-year rate.

Mr. Downe would not comment on discussions BMO may have held with Ottawa. However, after reports that policy makers were uncomfortable when the bank began offering record-low mortgage rates in January, BMO is said to
have signalled to Ottawa that another price cut was coming.

At a time when government and regulators are trying to warn Canadians about the perils of rising household debt levels, the bank’s goal was to explain to policy makers that the discounts aren’t risky or irresponsible from a lending perspective.

But market watchers suggest the reason behind BMO’s high-profile push on mortgages is to regain market share the bank has lost since 2007, when it decided to stop using mortgage brokers.

BMO wanted to increase margins by bringing mortgage sales inside its branches, rather than use commissioned middlemen to sell the products. Branch sales also allow the bank to cross-sell customers on other products.

Since 2007, BMO has seen its market share on mortgages fall significantly, to about 6.5 per cent from more than 9 per cent as a result. In a $1.1-trillion mortgage market, that drop is worth billions to the loan book. It also comes at a time when profit margins have also shrunk, due to low interest rates, putting added strain on the balance sheet.

“You can see that [BMO] are really aggressive in the market right now. And at 2.99 per cent, their spreads are tight and getting tighter,” said Robert McLister, a mortgage adviser in Vancouver and author of the Canadian Mortgage Trends blog. “So they’re obviously trying to get their name in headlines and start to get their market share going in the right direction.”

The drop in market share at BMO in the past four years is a key risk for CIBC, as it looks to potentially exit the mortgage broker channel in search of fatter margins. CIBC confirmed last week that it is looking to sell its FirstLine mortgage broker business to “put more emphasis on branch mortgage originations.”

Analysts are now concerned that CIBC will see a significant drop in market if the strategy backfires. BMO, for example, grew its mortgage book 2 per cent in 2011, which was well behind its peers who used brokers to push more sales.

“The execution risk inherent to [CIBC’s] bold decision to exit the mortgage broker distribution channel in Canada warrants a discount” on the stock price, National Bank Financial analyst Peter Routledge said in a research note.

At BMO, Mr. Downe said his bank has held talks with policy makers in Ottawa about the bank’s strategy of promoting shorter amortizations, something Ottawa favours.

“For the past two years, we have been advocating publicly for shorter amortizations and we have shared this point of view with government,” Mr. Downe said. “We have structured our offering based on maintaining margin,” he said.

grant robertson —
BANKING REPORTER

From Thursday’s Globe and Mail

Published

Great opportunity for buyers this Spring: Stable prices & historically low intrest rates.

Housing sales slow in valley

 But prices, new listings, are up in new year
 The Times February 9, 2012
 
 Home sales this January were the lowest since the start of 2009, but Fraser Valley realtors also saw one of the highest numbers of new listings come on line last month in the past decade.

The Fraser Valley Real Estate Board reported this week there were 2,753 new listings last month, five per cent more than in January 2011.

The increase in new inventory raised the volume of active properties in Fraser Valley to 8,320 by the end of January.

This is good news for home hunters, said board president Sukh Sidhu.

“For buying power you can’t beat the combination of greater selection, the continuation of extremely low interest rates and stable prices,” he said.

The board’s Multiple Listing Service processed actual 799 sales last month, four per cent less than in January 2011.

While home prices are dropped slightly in the last six months, overall prices are still up over last year.

The board’s new MLS Home Price Index, launched on Monday, shows the benchmark price of a detached home in the Fraser Valley in January was $567,700, an increase of 7.6 per cent compared to $527,500 in January 2011.

The benchmark price in January for townhouses was $314,200, an increase of 2.4 per cent compared to January last year.

The benchmark price of apartments in January was $199,600, a decrease of 0.1 per cent compared to January 2011 when it was $199,800.

The MLS® Home Price Index (HPI), replacing the Lower Mainland’s MLSLink® Housing Price Index, is a new measure of price for residential properties in five major markets across Canada.

It includes Greater Vancouver, Fraser Valley, Calgary, Toronto, and Montreal, with more markets to be added.

The new pricing index system was pioneered by six founding partners: the real estate boards of Calgary, Fraser Valley, Greater Montreal, Greater Vancouver, and Greater Toronto and the Canadian Real Estate Association.

Sidhu says the new MLS HPI will help agents in guiding homeowners.

“It’s a bigger, better tool to measure the change in home prices and now we can more accurately compare our market to other major cities in Canada,” he said.

© Copyright (c) Abbotsford Times

Read more: http://www.abbotsfordtimes.com/business/Housing+sales+slow+valley/6125070/story.html#ixzz1mIQETPwN

Carney holds the line on Rates

From the Globe & Mail December 6th, 2011:

Europe is hurtling toward a recession that will be worse than anticipated just weeks ago, darkening the outlook for Canada and its key trading partners.

The United States will feel the pinch of both the European slump and its own troubles, despite signs that Canada’s chief export market is getting back on its feet. Emerging markets, especially those that export heavily to Europe, are also slowing down. And while Canada trades far less with Europe than with countries like the United States and China, it will still feel the sting of a weaker global backdrop through “financial, confidence and trade channels,” the Bank of Canada says.

Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney and his policy team made those comments Tuesday as they held their main interest rate at 1 per cent, for a 10th consecutive time, warning that Europe’s downturn will be “more pronounced” than they projected in October in what was already a gloomy quarterly forecast.

Mr. Carney and his colleagues cited a deteriorating and increasingly unpredictable external climate in explaining their decision, adding that recent signs of improvement in Canada and the United States could prove to be short-lived as the euro zone crisis weighs on economies everywhere.

The warning comes early in a week when global markets threaten to swing back and forth as investors grope for hints that a crucial European summit on Dec. 9 in Brussels will yield real progress at stemming a melodrama which has dragged on for more than two years, escalating in recent weeks to dangerous new levels.

Some Canadian firms that do significant business in Europe are taking a wait-and-see approach, but overall confidence among exporters has dropped to its lowest level since the recession, according to a semi-annual survey released this month by Export Development Canada.

Exports were a key reason why the economy grew at a 3.5-per-cent annual pace in the third quarter, Statistics Canada said on Nov. 30, and consumer spending in the U.S. – still the destination for about 75 per cent of Canada’s exports, far more than European markets – has been surprisingly strong of late. However, that same report from Statscan also showed business investment fell during the three-month period, the first quarterly drop since 2009.

Don Lang, executive chairman of CCL Industries Inc., a Toronto-based specialty packaging company, said his company does about 40 per cent of its business in Europe, so he is naturally concerned. Nonetheless, he said his customers and suppliers have all been anticipating a European downturn for a while, and he hasn’t yet seen the kind of pullback one might expect.

More important, the company has increased its business with emerging markets in Asia and Latin America over the past decade, to about 19 per cent from low single-digits, and is concentrating its new investments in those regions, “because that’s where the growth is.”

“We’re going to protect our market share and positions in all the countries that we operate in,” he said. “But the majority of our new capital is going to the developing world, and developing economies.”

André Navarri, president and chief operating officer of Bombardier Transportation, said the impact from the debt crisis is minimal. He noted, though, that most of Bombardier’s rail customers are in Northern Europe, which has so far suffered much less impact than southern nations like Greece, Spain and Italy.

Mr. Carney has urged Canadian businesses to avoid feeling “paralyzed” by global uncertainty and to forge ahead with steps that will make them less dependent on the U.S. and Europe, where demand could be subpar for years.

On Nov. 23, he abandoned his script during a speech in Montreal, assuring his audience that Canada’s financial system can function “in difficult times,” and that Canada’s attractiveness to global investors will make it easier for companies to obtain access to capital at reasonable rates even as conditions tighten around the world.

Last week, the Bank of Canada and five other major central banks launched a co-ordinated bid to keep the world financial system sufficiently greased, and prevent a Lehman Brothers-esque scramble for cash that cripples credit markets. Most analysts, though, saw the move as a Band-Aid that buys European governments a bit more time to do their part to ensure a lasting solution.

“Additional measures will be required to contain the European crisis,” Mr. Carney said Tuesday.

 

Mortgage Insurance Rules Announcement

Federal Finance Minister Jim Flaherty announced prudent changes to mortgage insurance rules intended to come into force on April 19, 2010. The Canadian Association of Mortgage Professionals (CAAMP), were actively engaged in the discussions around these changes and they are as follows:

  1. All borrowers must meet the standards for a 5-year fixed rate mortgage even if they choose a mortgage with lower interest rate and term.
  2. (The maximum amount one can withdraw in refinancing their mortgage will be reduced to 90%, from the current 95% of the value of one’s home.
  3. Non-owner occupied properties will require a minimum down payment of 20%

There were no changes to down payment requirements or length of amortizations for owner-occupied residences. In conjunction with CAAMP, we will continue to monitor developments including transitions rules. This is all very positive news for the real estate market. Amortizations continue to remain at 35 years and minimum down payments have not changed for owner-occupied properties and remain at 5%. As far as borrowers having to qualify based on a 5-year fixed, we are going back to the way borrowers had to qualify a number of years ago. Clients all had to qualify on a 5 year fixed payment even if they went with a shorter term or variable mortgage versus closed. This is a protective stance to ensure buyers can afford their monthly payments and are not purring themselves at risk. Most lenders have already been qualifying clients this way and should not have a very strong impact on purchasers. The changes to refinances will not affect purchasers unless they are looking to take out additional funds over and above the cost of the home which will now be to a maximum of 90% – not 95%.

Property Tax Instructions and Links for your Convenience

It’s that time again….heading into summer and paying our property taxes. Taxes and sun, what could be better! You’ve probably just received, or will be receiving shortly, your tax notice in the mail. For your convenience, I have put together the various ways to pay your taxes and to register for your Home Owners Grant (HOG). Great acronym isn’t it!

Claiming Your Home Owner’s Grant: If your property is your principle residence you have to claim your Home Owners Grant (which is $570) some cities it is less. There are 2 ways for you to claim:

  1. Signing the tax notice and mailing or dropping it off at the city.
  2. You can also complete it online if your city has an electronic payment capability on their website. If you are doing this online you will need the folio number and access code which is on your notice. It takes no more than 5 minutes to complete. Don’t forget to print off a copy for your records.

Paying Your Property Taxes: There are 4 ways this can be done:

  1. Some lenders allow you to pay your property taxes throughout the year with your mortgage payment. If that is the case, the lender will remit the payment directly on your behalf. Be aware your taxes can change from year-to-year so it is a good idea to call your current lender to ensure you have enough in your account. If you do not have the lender number, simply give us a call and we can help.
  2. If your lender does not collect your taxes, you can write a post-dated cheque for July 2nd. and mail it to the city.
  3. You can also make your payment at most chartered banks.
  4. A great way to pay your taxes is to use your cities monthly preauthorized debit program. If you do not, it is a convenient option to consider going forward. Instructions will be on your cities website or attached to your tax notice.

As a helpful tool, I have also provided some links for more information and electronic payment details. Please note that I could not find an electronic payment option for Richmond or Langley. Please feel free to pass this email along to friends, family members and colleagues. As always, if you know of anyone needing financing, please do not keep us a secret. Our business is built on referrals from great clients like you!